If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#71
|
|||
|
|||
Winch Launch Fatality
In message , Del C
writes snip Some glass single seaters are very good at hiding the release knob almost out of reach somewhere below your crutch and behind the stick. On my own glider I have extended the cable so it is easier to reach the knob (with the approval of a BGA Inspector I hasten to add). The last fatal cartwheel accident in the UK involved an ASW20L glider. If you read the aaib report, they concluded that once the stick was hard over to the left, which it would have been as it was the right wing that dropped, it would have been almost impossible to get to the release knob if you weren't holding it already! Snip I might be wrong but I think they also concluded that having the left hand where it could reach the release knob would have made full left aileron impossible. My own glider has similarities with an ASW20 and also has a short extension on the release pull. -- Surfer! Email to: ramwater at uk2 dot net |
#72
|
|||
|
|||
Winch Launch Fatality
In message
, toad writes snip There is one less Discus in the world because the pilot had his hand on the release on a bumpy day. He "in-advertently" pulled the release at low altitude and crashed into the trees. The pilot was not injured, but the glider was totaled. If you want to keep your hand on the release, then hold it some way that prevents turbulence from releasing it for you. Since a launch can fail at any point, inadvertently releasing shouldn't lead to totalling the glider... -- Surfer! Email to: ramwater at uk2 dot net |
#73
|
|||
|
|||
Winch Launch Fatality
Once a wing drops onto the ground, the glider will almost inevitably veer
off in the same direction due to ground friction, which is what you see here and what you also see in my video of a wing drop. The photographer didn't quite catch the start of this incident, and I am sure that the glider would have been lined up correctly. The wing tip runner for the K13 was a very experienced pilot and an ex syndicate partner of mine. He told me that it was a cold, windy and very blustery day and that none of our runways lined up with the wind direction, so there was about a 30 degree cross wind from the right. The chain of events started with a violent gust that caused the wing to drop as he let go. The instructor tried to pull off, but his gloved hand slipped round the round release knob, twice in fact. He was successful at the third attempt, but reported that it took a lot more force than he expected to release under tension. By this time he was airborne, so had to take over and fight the glider back onto the ground somehow. What was interesting was the the eventual landing direction was at right angles to the start direction, once the rudder was taken off. The student pilot may not have dealt with the dropping wing very well, but there is no evidence that he contributed to it. After this incident, our CFI wanted to fit T handle releases to our K13s, but EASA said no because it counted as a major modification and would require full design approval (very expensive). Bureaucracy gone mad or what! Derek Copeland At 18:54 24 June 2009, bildan wrote: What I see in that K-13 sequence is the parachute disappearing off the left side of the frame after it was released. It gives the appearance the glider was staged at least 30 degrees off the line of sight to the winch. I also don't see any aileron or rudder applied in the first frame with the wing on the ground indicating the pilot was WAAY behind the glider. Blaming this 100% on a gust seems a reach. |
#74
|
|||
|
|||
Winch Launch Fatality
At 19:50 24 June 2009, Surfer! wrote:
In message , Del C writes Some glass single seaters are very good at hiding the release knob almost out of reach somewhere below your crutch and behind the stick. On my own glider I have extended the cable so it is easier to reach the knob (with the approval of a BGA Inspector I hasten to add). The last fatal cartwheel accident in the UK involved an ASW20L glider. If you read the aaib report, they concluded that once the stick was hard over to the left, which it would have been as it was the right wing that dropped, it would have been almost impossible to get to the release knob if you weren't holding it already! I might be wrong but I think they also concluded that having the left hand where it could reach the release knob would have made full left aileron impossible. Either way, it's not a desirable design feature.!!! Derek C |
#75
|
|||
|
|||
Winch Launch Fatality
On Wed, 24 Jun 2009 08:29:22 -0700 (PDT), bildan
wrote: It's realistic in the sense that the most likely way a wing would go down is if the pilot does, in fact, "stuff it down". Unfortunately, you just have to watch a few takeoffs to see it happen. One of my frustrations is pilots who seem to have no idea where their ailerons are until a wingtip hits the ground. If the pilot consciously centers the ailerons as part of the pre- takeoff checks and lets the wing runner balance the glider, the glider will just stay balanced on its own for several seconds after the wing runner lets go - long enough to get aileron control on either aero tow or winch. That's good practice with any launch method. Hi Bill, I'm not sure if your observation is correct. During aerotows you often see the wing runner working hard to keep the wing perfectly balanced, the pilot keeps ailerons centered, wing runner lets go - and the wing tip hits the ground immediately before the pilot has time to apply aileron. A typical crosswind situation. The problem is that the pilot cannot sense the wing-drop tendency (and apply opposite aileron) as long as the wing runner keeps the wing level. The better technique is if the wing runner follows the wing-drop tendency, not trying to keep the wings level - the pilot is going to feel one wing going down (although still held by the wing runner, hence no danger of the wing tip touching the ground) and will apply aileron immediately. This usually works like a charm. And then there were those open class ships in crosswind situations where you have to apply full aileron to the lee side from the beginning of the aerotow (even if this wing drops)... because despite full aileron this side it's going to come up again..... |
#76
|
|||
|
|||
Winch Launch Fatality
What is particularly interesting in both the video and the photographs is
the direction the glider is pointing relative to the cable. In the video the glider can be seen to yaw as the cable tightens and then further yaw as the it starts to move. In the photographs it is clear that the glider is pointing to the right of the direction of the cable AND stangely is pointed in the same direction as the K13 parked behind it, a co-incidence perhaps. In both cases it would appear possible that the glider was not lined up with the cable prior to launch so that as soon as the cable moved yaw was induced. With a CofG hook the glider will be more unstable about the yaw axis than was the case with the more forward release on older gliders. Perhaps that might explain why this appears to be a "new" phenomenon. At 21:45 24 June 2009, Derek Copeland wrote: Once a wing drops onto the ground, the glider will almost inevitably veer off in the same direction due to ground friction, which is what you see here and what you also see in my video of a wing drop. The photographer didn't quite catch the start of this incident, and I am sure that the glider would have been lined up correctly. The wing tip runner for the K13 was a very experienced pilot and an ex syndicate partner of mine. He told me that it was a cold, windy and very blustery day and that none of our runways lined up with the wind direction, so there was about a 30 degree cross wind from the right. The chain of events started with a violent gust that caused the wing to drop as he let go. The instructor tried to pull off, but his gloved hand slipped round the round release knob, twice in fact. He was successful at the third attempt, but reported that it took a lot more force than he expected to release under tension. By this time he was airborne, so had to take over and fight the glider back onto the ground somehow. What was interesting was the the eventual landing direction was at right angles to the start direction, once the rudder was taken off. The student pilot may not have dealt with the dropping wing very well, but there is no evidence that he contributed to it. After this incident, our CFI wanted to fit T handle releases to our K13s, but EASA said no because it counted as a major modification and would require full design approval (very expensive). Bureaucracy gone mad or what! Derek Copeland At 18:54 24 June 2009, bildan wrote: What I see in that K-13 sequence is the parachute disappearing off the left side of the frame after it was released. It gives the appearance the glider was staged at least 30 degrees off the line of sight to the winch. I also don't see any aileron or rudder applied in the first frame with the wing on the ground indicating the pilot was WAAY behind the glider. Blaming this 100% on a gust seems a reach. |
#77
|
|||
|
|||
Winch Launch Fatality
The apparent cable offset was because we were using a retrieve winch.
However the cable always pulled approximately straight under tension as the launch commenced. It was normal to place the launch queue on the downwind side of the retrieve winch, so that any slight weather-cocking at the start of the launch if anything further reduced the angle between the cable and the glider, and also reduced the possibility of the wind getting under the upwind wing. The gliders would have been set up to point at the main winch, or just slightly upwind of it to reduce any yaw at the start. IMHO the use of a retrieve winch actually reduces the possibility of a wing drop, and was not a factor in either case. Particularly in the video, the glider was running straight before the wing drop occured, and was probably due to the student pilot failing to do anything positive to keep the wings level in a slight cross wind from the right, plus a late take-over by a very newly qualified (at the time) instructor. Derek Copeland At 01:00 25 June 2009, Don Johnstone wrote: What is particularly interesting in both the video and the photographs is the direction the glider is pointing relative to the cable. In the video the glider can be seen to yaw as the cable tightens and then further yaw as the it starts to move. In the photographs it is clear that the glider is pointing to the right of the direction of the cable AND stangely is pointed in the same direction as the K13 parked behind it, a co-incidence perhaps. In both cases it would appear possible that the glider was not lined up with the cable prior to launch so that as soon as the cable moved yaw was induced. With a CofG hook the glider will be more unstable about the yaw axis than was the case with the more forward release on older gliders. Perhaps that might explain why this appears to be a "new" phenomenon. At 21:45 24 June 2009, Derek Copeland wrote: Once a wing drops onto the ground, the glider will almost inevitably veer off in the same direction due to ground friction, which is what you see here and what you also see in my video of a wing drop. The photographer didn't quite catch the start of this incident, and I am sure that the glider would have been lined up correctly. The wing tip runner for the K13 was a very experienced pilot and an ex syndicate partner of mine. He told me that it was a cold, windy and very blustery day and that none of our runways lined up with the wind direction, so there was about a 30 degree cross wind from the right. The chain of events started with a violent gust that caused the wing to drop as he let go. The instructor tried to pull off, but his gloved hand slipped round the round release knob, twice in fact. He was successful at the third attempt, but reported that it took a lot more force than he expected to release under tension. By this time he was airborne, so had to take over and fight the glider back onto the ground somehow. What was interesting was the the eventual landing direction was at right angles to the start direction, once the rudder was taken off. The student pilot may not have dealt with the dropping wing very well, but there is no evidence that he contributed to it. After this incident, our CFI wanted to fit T handle releases to our K13s, but EASA said no because it counted as a major modification and would require full design approval (very expensive). Bureaucracy gone mad or what! Derek Copeland At 18:54 24 June 2009, bildan wrote: What I see in that K-13 sequence is the parachute disappearing off the left side of the frame after it was released. It gives the appearance the glider was staged at least 30 degrees off the line of sight to the winch. I also don't see any aileron or rudder applied in the first frame with the wing on the ground indicating the pilot was WAAY behind the glider. Blaming this 100% on a gust seems a reach. |
#78
|
|||
|
|||
Winch Launch Fatality
On Jun 24, 4:38*pm, Andreas Maurer wrote:
On Wed, 24 Jun 2009 08:29:22 -0700 (PDT), bildan wrote: It's realistic in the sense that the most likely way a wing would go down is if the pilot does, in fact, "stuff it down". *Unfortunately, you just have to watch a few takeoffs to see it happen. *One of my frustrations is pilots who seem to have no idea where their ailerons are until a wingtip hits the ground. If the pilot consciously centers the ailerons as part of the pre- takeoff checks and lets the wing runner balance the glider, the glider will just stay balanced on its own for several seconds after the wing runner lets go *- long enough to get aileron control on either aero tow or winch. *That's good practice with any launch method. Hi Bill, I'm not sure if your observation is correct. During aerotows you often see the wing runner working hard to keep the wing perfectly balanced, the pilot keeps ailerons centered, wing runner lets go - and the wing tip hits the ground immediately before the pilot has time to apply aileron. A typical crosswind situation. The problem is that the pilot cannot sense the wing-drop tendency (and apply opposite aileron) as long as the wing runner keeps the wing level. The better technique is if the wing runner follows the wing-drop tendency, not trying to keep the wings level - the pilot is going to feel one wing going down (although still held by the wing runner, hence no danger of the wing tip touching the ground) and will apply aileron immediately. This usually works like a charm. And then there were those open class ships in crosswind situations where you have to apply full aileron to the lee side from the beginning of the aerotow (even if this wing drops)... because despite full aileron this side it's going to come up again..... If the wing runner balances the glider into the crosswind while the pilot holds neutral aileron it will work just fine, but the two have to work together. The wing runner should feel for the tilt into the wind that balances the glider so it's a tossup which wing would fall if he let go but he can only do this if the ailerons are neutral. Another instructor and I worked this out long ago. Since we often ran wings for each other it was easy to teach the technique to our students. (Ailerons neutral until the wing runner lets go - then fly the glider with the same bank into the wind as the wing runner gave you.) If the wing runner just "holds the wing level" it may well drop to the ground when he lets go. If the pilot is wagging the ailerons around, the wing runner can't do anything to help. BTW, there's another 'gotcha' you often see with aero tow takeoffs in crosswinds. A crosswind will blow the tugs propeller blast downwind so it hits the gliders downwind wing. The glider encounters the prop blast after rolling about half the towrope length. Usually by then the pilot is holding into-the-wind aileron which together with the prop blast will slam the upwind wing into the ground before the pilot reacts. If you are ready for it, you can handle it OK but it catches many pilots unaware. |
#79
|
|||
|
|||
Winch Launch Fatality
On Jun 24, 7:00*pm, Don Johnstone wrote:
What is particularly interesting in both the video and the photographs is the direction the glider is pointing relative to the cable. In the video the glider can be seen to yaw as the cable tightens and then further yaw as the it starts to move. In the photographs it is clear that the glider is pointing to the right of the direction of the cable AND stangely is pointed in the same direction as the K13 parked behind it, a co-incidence perhaps. In both cases it would appear possible that the glider was not lined up with the cable prior to launch so that as soon as the cable moved yaw was induced. With a CofG hook the glider will be more unstable about the yaw axis than was the case with the more forward release on older gliders. Perhaps that might explain why this appears to be a "new" phenomenon. Nope, they lined it up at an angle to the wire then all the other stuff compounded the problem. There are other videos from Lasham with the gliders improperly staged which show a similar wobbly takeoff. If the gilder isn't pointing at the winch, the takeoff will be 'interesting'. Unfortunately, some people in the US are showing the k-13 photo sequence as proof that winches are too dangerous to use. This actually forced me to add a paragraph in my winch training syllabus cautioning pilots to aim gliders at the winch - which any kid launching a balsa glider with a rubber band would understand without being told. To be fair, there very well could have been a wind event that we, in a dustier climate, would call a "dust devil" which couldn't be seen in lush green England. We would see it coming and stand down until the thing passed - then launch and go chase it for the lift it marks. |
#80
|
|||
|
|||
Winch Launch Fatality
For Christs sake Bill! Lasham is the largest and most professional gliding
club in the UK and we do about 10,000 winch launches per year, 9,999 of which go without incident. We do know what we are doing. We either point the glide directly at the main winch, or just slightly upwind of it in a crosswind to reduce any initial yaw due to weather cocking. The K13 incident was caused by a gust, and the glider was landed without damage or injury. A similar wing drop during an aerotow would be considered quite unremarkable. The correct thing to do is to pull off if a wing drops during a winch launch. Derek Copeland At 03:42 26 June 2009, bildan wrote: On Jun 24, 7:00=A0pm, Don Johnstone wrote: What is particularly interesting in both the video and the photographs is the direction the glider is pointing relative to the cable. In the video the glider can be seen to yaw as the cable tightens and then further yaw as the it starts to move. In the photographs it is clear that the glider is pointing to the right o= f the direction of the cable AND stangely is pointed in the same direction = as the K13 parked behind it, a co-incidence perhaps. In both cases it would appear possible that the glider was not lined up with the cable prior to launch so that as soon as the cable moved yaw was induced. With a CofG hook the glider will be more unstable about the yaw axis than was the cas= e with the more forward release on older gliders. Perhaps that might explai= n why this appears to be a "new" phenomenon. Nope, they lined it up at an angle to the wire then all the other stuff compounded the problem. There are other videos from Lasham with the gliders improperly staged which show a similar wobbly takeoff. If the gilder isn't pointing at the winch, the takeoff will be 'interesting'. Unfortunately, some people in the US are showing the k-13 photo sequence as proof that winches are too dangerous to use. This actually forced me to add a paragraph in my winch training syllabus cautioning pilots to aim gliders at the winch - which any kid launching a balsa glider with a rubber band would understand without being told. To be fair, there very well could have been a wind event that we, in a dustier climate, would call a "dust devil" which couldn't be seen in lush green England. We would see it coming and stand down until the thing passed - then launch and go chase it for the lift it marks. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Pay out winch launch to 2500ft agl.. | WAVEGURU | Soaring | 8 | June 5th 07 07:06 AM |
Winch Launch Videos | Mike Schumann | Soaring | 2 | January 19th 06 11:27 PM |
LIppmann reports a 950 meter winch launch with their Dynatec winch line - anything higher? | Bill Daniels | Soaring | 20 | December 27th 04 12:33 AM |
Electric winch fatality story in August Soaring | Bill Daniels | Soaring | 0 | August 14th 04 02:37 AM |
Winch launch | M B | Soaring | 0 | October 30th 03 07:33 PM |