Flight plan when crossing the boarder

Does anyone know the actual reason you're required to file a flight
plan when crossing the boarding between the U.S. and Canada? Does
someone sit down at the end of the year and try to count operations
based on them? They carry NO customs benefit since customs are handled
separately.

Usually, when we fly south into Mexico, we don't both filing since the
U.S. has no way to actually hand the flight plan to Mexico. Most of
the Mexico AOI don't even have working phones, much less computers.
However, they are always happy to see you arrive at any time. Of
course crossing the ADIZ northbound from Mexico is a different thing
all together.

-Robert

In a previous article, (Robert M. Gary) said:
Does anyone know the actual reason you're required to file a flight
plan when crossing the boarding between the U.S. and Canada? Does

Because if you don't, they'll send a pair of F-16s out to check you out.
And then, if they decide not to shoot you down, they send you a bill for
the fuel the F-16s used. You don't want that. :-)

--
Paul Tomblin http://xcski.com/blogs/pt/
My family's values included "Always state your assumptions and your evidence",
"first find out what the problem is, then fix it", and "feed your horse before
yourself". But you don't see people legislating those... -- Zeebee

(Paul Tomblin) wrote in news:ccaeba$uvt$1
@allhats.xcski.com:

In a previous article, (Robert M. Gary) said:
Does anyone know the actual reason you're required to file a flight
plan when crossing the boarding between the U.S. and Canada? Does

Because if you don't, they'll send a pair of F-16s out to check you out.
And then, if they decide not to shoot you down, they send you a bill for
the fuel the F-16s used. You don't want that. :-)


What happens if you overfly Canada, but not land? Do you need to file a
flight plan for that too? Admittedly, the only times I have done that were
under IFR, but I don't see why VFR aircraft would be any different.

"Robert M. Gary" wrote in message
om...
Does anyone know the actual reason you're required to file a flight
plan when crossing the boarding between the U.S. and Canada? Does
someone sit down at the end of the year and try to count operations
based on them? They carry NO customs benefit since customs are handled
separately.

Filing a flight plan when crossing an international border is an ICAO
requirement. Of course that doesn't explain why the requirement hasn't been
waived for convenience between the US and Canada, as have many other
requirements that are standard for international stuff. But it does mean
that it would be a question of overriding the default, which may take
unanimity between diverse Canadian departments. Maybe some of them have
access to Google? :-) http://www.invadecanada.us/

Julian Scarfe

In a previous article, Andrew Sarangan said:
What happens if you overfly Canada, but not land? Do you need to file a
flight plan for that too? Admittedly, the only times I have done that were
under IFR, but I don't see why VFR aircraft would be any different.

Yes, you do.

It's even supposed to be helpful if you put "OVERFLIGHT" in the remarks
section, don't know if that's true.

--
Paul Tomblin http://xcski.com/blogs/pt/
We are not gentle tolerant people. We like drastically effective solutions.
-- Steve VanDevender

In a previous article, "Julian Scarfe" said:
requirements that are standard for international stuff. But it does mean
that it would be a question of overriding the default, which may take
unanimity between diverse Canadian departments. Maybe some of them have
access to Google? :-) http://www.invadecanada.us/

How do you know it's Canada that's being intransegent? Look at how much
better CANPASS is than GATE, and you can see that it's the US that is
scared to let their guard down even a little.

Besides:
http://cwd.ptbcanadian.com/



--
Paul Tomblin http://xcski.com/blogs/pt/
You really know you're in trouble when your boss decides upon a suicide
pact... and agrees to go first.
-- Chris King

(Paul Tomblin) wrote in
:

In a previous article, Andrew Sarangan said:
What happens if you overfly Canada, but not land? Do you need to file
a flight plan for that too? Admittedly, the only times I have done
that were under IFR, but I don't see why VFR aircraft would be any
different.

Yes, you do.

It's even supposed to be helpful if you put "OVERFLIGHT" in the
remarks section, don't know if that's true.


I thought you only had to file if you were more than 25 miles in Canada?

(Paul Tomblin) wrote in message ...
In a previous article, (Robert M. Gary) said:
Does anyone know the actual reason you're required to file a flight
plan when crossing the boarding between the U.S. and Canada? Does

Because if you don't, they'll send a pair of F-16s out to check you out.
And then, if they decide not to shoot you down, they send you a bill for
the fuel the F-16s used. You don't want that. :-)

That just doesn't make any sense though. If you are talking to ATC,
they would just ask you what you are doing. Remember though, there is
no ADIZ between Canada and the U.S. If you decide not to talk to ATC
as you cross you wouldn't have a transponder code so they can't tell
the difference between the planes that have filed and those that have
not. They all just look like dots on the radar. How would they know
the difference? When you cross the ADIZ (like from Mexico), you get
your own code and everything, its very different.

-Robert

In a previous article, (Robert M. Gary) said:
(Paul Tomblin) wrote in message
...
In a previous article, (Robert M. Gary) said:
Does anyone know the actual reason you're required to file a flight
plan when crossing the boarding between the U.S. and Canada? Does

Because if you don't, they'll send a pair of F-16s out to check you out.
And then, if they decide not to shoot you down, they send you a bill for
the fuel the F-16s used. You don't want that. :-)

That just doesn't make any sense though. If you are talking to ATC,
they would just ask you what you are doing. Remember though, there is
no ADIZ between Canada and the U.S. If you decide not to talk to ATC
as you cross you wouldn't have a transponder code so they can't tell
the difference between the planes that have filed and those that have
not. They all just look like dots on the radar. How would they know

Since 9/11, aircraft crossing the border are required to be on a flight
plan AND in communication with ATC, either VFR Flight Following or IFR.
When flying across southern Ontario talking to Toronto Center, I was
continually hearing Canadian pilots calling up near the border to get
flight following across the border. That's in contrast to American
pilots, who seem to get flight following the whole way there.

--
Paul Tomblin http://xcski.com/blogs/pt/
A bleeding heart can be hell on the carpeting.

Andrew Sarangan wrote in message .158...
(Paul Tomblin) wrote in
:


I thought you only had to file if you were more than 25 miles in Canada?


In addition, you also have to file anytime you cross a border.