circumnavigating Chicago Class B

Hey all,

I'm looking at flying my PA 28-161 VFR from Minneapolis to South Bend,
Indiana, in a few weeks for a Notre Dame football game (go irish!). Two
big things, of course, stand in my way: Lake Michigan and the Chicago
Class B airspace.

I've looked at the Chicago Terminal Chart, and have come up with two
possibilities:

1.) Aim for the OBK VOR, then skirt under Class Bravo at 2,900, and hug
the lakeshore all the way around to South Bend.

2.) Take 'er up to 11,500 in southcentral Wisconsin, go above the Class
B airspace. I've never been up that high before! This might let me cut
a little deeper across Lake Michigan.

3.) Accept a transition through Class B from ATC.

I'm a pretty new VFR pilot (you might remember my Duluth post) with
about 80 hrs... but am very comfortable communicating with ATC in /
around MSP Class B airspace.

I will, as always, have VFR flight following. Will ATC be expecting me
to choose one of the above options when I approach Chicagoland? How
much ATC interaction should I expect while I'm over / under their
airspace? Maybe just handoffs?

Also, Meigs Class D is still on the chart. Is it really still in
effect/operation?

Thanks a ton!

Neil Bratney
PP-ASEL

"Neil Bratney" wrote in message
...
Hey all,

I'm looking at flying my PA 28-161 VFR from Minneapolis to South Bend,
Indiana, in a few weeks for a Notre Dame football game (go irish!). Two
big things, of course, stand in my way: Lake Michigan and the Chicago
Class B airspace.

I've looked at the Chicago Terminal Chart, and have come up with two
possibilities:

1.) Aim for the OBK VOR, then skirt under Class Bravo at 2,900, and hug
the lakeshore all the way around to South Bend.

2.) Take 'er up to 11,500 in southcentral Wisconsin, go above the Class
B airspace. I've never been up that high before! This might let me cut
a little deeper across Lake Michigan.

3.) Accept a transition through Class B from ATC.

I'm a pretty new VFR pilot (you might remember my Duluth post) with
about 80 hrs... but am very comfortable communicating with ATC in /
around MSP Class B airspace.

I will, as always, have VFR flight following. Will ATC be expecting me
to choose one of the above options when I approach Chicagoland? How
much ATC interaction should I expect while I'm over / under their
airspace? Maybe just handoffs?

Also, Meigs Class D is still on the chart. Is it really still in
effect/operation?

Thanks a ton!

Neil Bratney
PP-ASEL


in reverse order meigs is just a park now it is a class nothing.
flight following around ohare? you can try but dont count on it.
getting a transition through the class B? not a chance in hell.

climb above the class b? i wouldnt, there is a lot of high speed traffic
up there.
if the weather is good just head down the shoreline at about 2000 feet it
is really neat.
if the weather is a bit iffy head for the dupage vor to joliet vor then
gary

tony zambon
9941L

tony zambon wrote:

"Neil Bratney wrote:

2.) Take 'er up to 11,500 in southcentral Wisconsin, go above the
Class
B airspace. I've never been up that high before!

climb above the class b? i wouldnt, there is a lot of high speed
traffic up there.

I've done that (11,500 a couple of times), and it works fine. I've
never seen a "lot" of high speed traffic at that (or any other) level
that I fly at. All the small stuff is lower, and all the big stuff is
higher. All the big stuff down low is IN the "B", hence the "B" :-).
Plus, you can go in a straight line.

if the weather is good just head down the shoreline at about 2000
feet it
is really neat.

Agreed - it's wonderful in NYC - I imagine the same would be true for
Chicago.

--
Marc J. Zeitlin
http://marc.zeitlin.home.comcast.net/
http://www.cozybuilders.org/
Copyright (c) 2004

climb above the class b? i wouldnt, there is a lot of high speed traffic
up there.


Baloney. All that "high speed traffic" is either taking off or landing
(way down below you) or is overflying waaaayyy above you at 11.5 or
12.5. Overflying is the safest place to be. The view is great as
well (assuming good weather)

Been there, done that

David Johnson

"David Johnson" wrote in message
om...
climb above the class b? i wouldnt, there is a lot of high speed
traffic
up there.


Baloney. All that "high speed traffic" is either taking off or landing
(way down below you) or is overflying waaaayyy above you at 11.5 or
12.5. Overflying is the safest place to be. The view is great as
well (assuming good weather)

Been there, done that

David Johnson

sorry but i have to disagree. flying over the top of ohare is not a
good place to be. if you dont believe me check out the STARs, most have the
inbounds crossing various fixes at 30 to 40 miles out at 11,000 ft.

tony zambon
grumman
9941L

sorry but i have to disagree. flying over the top of ohare is not a
good place to be. if you dont believe me check out the STARs, most have the
inbounds crossing various fixes at 30 to 40 miles out at 11,000 ft.

I've been flying VFR over the top of O'Hare for the past 20 years. Almost no
traffic up there. I find all of the traffic below 10,000' and above 4000'
around the sides of the class B. But then again, I transition over the top in
excess of 250 knots. For slower VFR, I'd recommend lake shore or the west side
as previous posts have described.
VL

I have flown the low altitude route as well as over the top VFR and much
prefer the high altitude. If you have an engine problem you have a lot more
options, and traffic is a lot more visible up high.

Don't forget that all of the heavy iron has TCAS and will see you on the
screen well before you see them.

"Neil Bratney" wrote in message
...
Hey all,

I'm looking at flying my PA 28-161 VFR from Minneapolis to South Bend,
Indiana, in a few weeks for a Notre Dame football game (go irish!). Two
big things, of course, stand in my way: Lake Michigan and the Chicago
Class B airspace.

I've looked at the Chicago Terminal Chart, and have come up with two
possibilities:

1.) Aim for the OBK VOR, then skirt under Class Bravo at 2,900, and hug
the lakeshore all the way around to South Bend.

2.) Take 'er up to 11,500 in southcentral Wisconsin, go above the Class
B airspace. I've never been up that high before! This might let me cut
a little deeper across Lake Michigan.

3.) Accept a transition through Class B from ATC.

I'm a pretty new VFR pilot (you might remember my Duluth post) with
about 80 hrs... but am very comfortable communicating with ATC in /
around MSP Class B airspace.

I will, as always, have VFR flight following. Will ATC be expecting me
to choose one of the above options when I approach Chicagoland? How
much ATC interaction should I expect while I'm over / under their
airspace? Maybe just handoffs?

Also, Meigs Class D is still on the chart. Is it really still in
effect/operation?

Thanks a ton!

Neil Bratney
PP-ASEL


If you have never transited the lake shore it is a million dollar ride and
definitely worth doing.

If you have never transited the lake shore it is a million dollar ride and
definitely worth doing.

I enthusiasticallly second that; it's the way I go to and return from
OSH.

But when I go from central PA down to the Outer Banks, I go over
Dulles above the Class B. Works great.

vince norris

Chances of continuing flight following around Chicago is 50/50. Sounding
professional and time of day determines your chance of getting handed off.
Chances of tranisitioning the class B is zero. The lakeshore ride is the
better view. If the weather is iffy, stay west.

Most people transition the lakeshore at 2000. Personally, I do it at 2200 or
1800. Keep your eyes open. With Meigs gone, there is no one controlling the
lakeshore anymore. Talk to Gary around the south side.

If you want to talk, send me an email.
--
-------------------------------
Travis
"Neil Bratney" wrote in message
...
Hey all,

I'm looking at flying my PA 28-161 VFR from Minneapolis to South Bend,
Indiana, in a few weeks for a Notre Dame football game (go irish!). Two
big things, of course, stand in my way: Lake Michigan and the Chicago
Class B airspace.

I've looked at the Chicago Terminal Chart, and have come up with two
possibilities:

1.) Aim for the OBK VOR, then skirt under Class Bravo at 2,900, and hug
the lakeshore all the way around to South Bend.

2.) Take 'er up to 11,500 in southcentral Wisconsin, go above the Class
B airspace. I've never been up that high before! This might let me cut
a little deeper across Lake Michigan.

3.) Accept a transition through Class B from ATC.

I'm a pretty new VFR pilot (you might remember my Duluth post) with
about 80 hrs... but am very comfortable communicating with ATC in /
around MSP Class B airspace.

I will, as always, have VFR flight following. Will ATC be expecting me
to choose one of the above options when I approach Chicagoland? How
much ATC interaction should I expect while I'm over / under their
airspace? Maybe just handoffs?

Also, Meigs Class D is still on the chart. Is it really still in
effect/operation?

Thanks a ton!

Neil Bratney
PP-ASEL